MSCI's Digital Asset Review: Pressure Mounts for Treasury Companies

In the rapidly evolving world of digital assets, a significant announcement from MSCI, a leading global provider of equity, fixed income, and benchmark indexes, is sending ripples through the **digital asset treasury (DAT)** space. The potential exclusion of companies with over 50% of their balance sheets in crypto assets from MSCI indexes could exert considerable pressure on these entities.

MSCI initiated a consultation in October, seeking feedback on whether to exclude DATs. The core of their concern, as noted, is that these companies can **“exhibit characteristics similar to investment funds, which are currently not eligible for index inclusion.”** This signals a growing need for clarity and structure within the digital asset ecosystem, a need that **RWA Times** is actively addressing.

The Consultation and Potential Impact

Charlie Sherry, Head of Finance at BTC Markets, believes the odds are **“solidly in favour of it”** happening. He points out that MSCI typically initiates such consultations when they are already leaning towards a particular decision. The consultation period is set to close on December 31st, with conclusions announced on January 15th, and any changes implemented in February.

MSCI is also seeking input on additional parameters, such as a company’s self-definition as a DAT or if its capital raising was primarily aimed at accumulating crypto. If DATs are indeed excluded, index-tracking funds would be compelled to divest their holdings, leading to **“meaningful pressure”** on the affected companies. A preliminary list from MSCI identifies **38 crypto companies** under review, including prominent names like MicroStrategy, Riot Platforms, and Marathon Digital Holdings.

“When most of the value comes from a balance-sheet asset rather than the underlying business, MSCI treats that as outside the scope of a traditional equity benchmark,” Sherry explained. “It’s a risk-management decision designed to keep indexes aligned with predictable business fundamentals.”

This move marks a notable shift. While crypto-heavy corporate strategies were once lauded as capital markets innovations, large index providers are now tightening their definitions. This suggests the market is moving beyond an “everything is adoption” phase and adopting a **more conservative filter**, a trend that requires sophisticated analysis to navigate.

“This also marks a shift in tone from the past year. Crypto-heavy corporate strategies were applauded as a capital markets innovation. Now the large index providers are tightening their definitions, and it shows that the market is moving out of its everything is adoption phase and back toward a more conservative filter.”

JPMorgan analysts have already warned that MicroStrategy could shed an estimated $2.8 billion, with roughly $9 billion of its market value tied to passive funds tracked by indexes. This underscores the significant financial implications of MSCI’s decision.

Will Other Indexes Follow Suit?

The question remains whether other index providers will follow MSCI’s lead. Sherry suggests it’s **“hard to call at this stage.”** While index providers often monitor each other’s actions, they don’t always move in lockstep. The S&P’s stricter view on MicroStrategy serves as a precedent, but each provider has its own methodology and client base to consider.

“If MSCI makes a change, it could open the door for others to review their own rules, but it doesn’t guarantee a chain reaction,” Sherry added. Despite the current uncertainty, MicroStrategy reportedly remains on track for possible inclusion in the S&P 500, according to 10X Research, which had predicted a 70% chance of this before year-end.

The Value of Clearer Rules in a Tokenizing World

While short-term impacts might be uncomfortable for some companies, Sherry emphasizes that clearer rules around corporate classification ultimately **benefit the digital asset space**. When companies understand precisely how their treasury decisions will be treated, it removes uncertainty for both issuers and investors. This is particularly crucial as the broader market moves towards the **tokenization of real-world assets (RWAs)**, a trend that promises to redefine financial markets.

At **RWA Times**, we’ve built our platform precisely to address this growing need for clarity and structured intelligence. Our proprietary **AI-powered taxonomy**, featuring over 40 distinct topics, meticulously categorizes and analyzes financial news related to the **tokenized real-world asset** sector. We go beyond simple keyword tagging, employing advanced Natural Language Processing (NLP) to understand the core context and market implications of every piece of information.

Whether it's understanding the nuances of **asset types**, tracking **jurisdictional developments**, or analyzing **legal and regulatory frameworks**, our **RWA Times Intelligence Engine** provides the precise insights needed. We score content based on characteristics like sentiment, novelty (entropy), and relevance to the RWA mandate, ensuring that our users receive actionable market intelligence, not just raw data.

The current regulatory scrutiny highlighted by the MSCI review is a clear signal of the market’s maturation. As the RWA sector continues its exponential growth—projected to be a multi-trillion-dollar market by 2030—navigating this landscape requires more than just a news feed. It demands a sophisticated intelligence system. **RWA Times** offers that system, providing the structure and analytical depth necessary to make informed decisions in this dynamic new era of finance.

“Well-defined frameworks tend to strengthen long-term institutional confidence, even if the short-term impact is uncomfortable for stocks built around Bitcoin holdings.”

Embrace Clarity in the Tokenization Revolution

The potential exclusion of DATs from MSCI indexes underscores the critical need for robust classification and transparent methodologies. As the financial world increasingly embraces the **tokenization of real-world assets**, having tools that can systematically analyze and present this complex information is paramount for businesses, fanpage administrators, and institutional investors alike.

If you're looking to stay ahead of the curve in the **RWA tokenization** space, understand market sentiment, and identify emerging trends with confidence, **RWA Times** is your essential partner. We transform the chaos of financial news into structured, actionable intelligence.

Ready to decode the future of finance? Explore the RWA Times Intelligence Engine today and gain a competitive edge in the rapidly expanding world of tokenized assets.

Learn More:

RWA Times